Originally written by Dr. Warren
and the Medical Advisory Board
of the Post Polio Program
Easter Seal Society of Oregon
MEDICAL ADVISORY BOARD
POLIO OUTREACH ADVISORY COUNCIL
A Working Advisory Council to the Easter Seal Society of Washington
|Joshua Benditt, MD, Pulmonologist||Bill Kelly, Physical Therapist|
|Evan Cantini, MD, Physiatrist||Dennis Lang, RN, MPH, Polio Survivor|
|Dianna Chamblin, MD, Physiatrist||Lawrence R. Robinson, MD, Physiatrist|
|Margarette Forgette, MD, Physiatrist||Mark Sumi, MD, Neurologist|
A. Definition of Post Polio
B. Scope of the Problem
C. Diagnostic Criteria
II. Pathology: Physiologic and Clinical Consequences
A. Extensive Neuronal Involvement in the
B. Motor Unit Remodeling
C. Decompensation Then Produces Post Polio Syndrome
III. Patient Presentation
A. Prime Symptoms
B. Additional Presenting Symptoms
C. Past History
IV. Evaluation Process
A. Identify Areas of Dysfunction
B. Formalize Treatment Goals
V. Resources in Patient Management
A. Neurology Consultation
B. Physiatry (Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation)
C. Physical Therapy
D. Occupational Therapy
E. Speech Pathology
H. Support Groups
Polio survivors are at risk for the occurrence of certain physiologic changes in the nervous system which result in a characteristic set of symptoms now known as Post Polio Syndrome. In addition to these unexpected physiological changes there are anticipated complications such as arthritis, scoliosis, and entrapment syndromes that frequently accompany paralytic conditions. These anticipated complications are not the problems that distinguish PPS from other diseases of the nervous system. Post Polio Syndrome (PPS) is a major chronic illness and one which poses unique problems to its survivors and their physicians.
No Diagnostic test exists for PPS, so clinical criteria must be used to establish the diagnosis. Many Physicians lack training in the diagnosis and management of a syndrome only recently acknowledged as existing. Patients are often uncomfortable with physicians they feel do not understand their problems. They also fear increased disability, often at the same time they are coping with limitations of aging. Patients are often trapped in a "conquer the disease" mentality derived from the experience of recovering from the acute episode an average of 25 years earlier. This is incompatible with the lifestyle adjustments necessary for optimal results in PPS rehabilitation.
An otherwise unexplained constellation of symptoms which may include weakness, fatigue, pain, heat or cold intolerance, and swallowing, breathing, or sleep disturbance developing in a patient who had paralytic polio. Post Polio Muscle Atrophy (PPMA) has been used as the label for the above symptoms when they include progressive muscle atrophy.
1987 National Health Interview Survey estimated 1.63 million American polio survivors (=0.625% of population), 50% with some Post Polio Syndrome symptoms.
While a single underlying etiology for PPS has not been proven, several theories exist:
A common presentation is a polio survivor who previously had lower extremity involvement in a well defined polio episode. The patient may have restricted ambulation from hiking or jogging, lived a sedentary life, and did not feel disabled. After a period of relatively stability he or she may begin to notice unusual fatigue and discomfort and may further restrict activity. Denial of decreased functional capacity may lead to a crisis as the patient can no longer can meet occupational, social, and family commitments. Persistence and attempts to continue at a previous activity level may lead to a downward spiral of decreasing functional capacity with resulting depression and despair. On examination, relative obesity may be present and weakness is easily demonstrated, often in the "good" leg; limbs considered unaffected are often subclinically affected with polio and may present with "new" polio. A statistical summary of the clinical characteristics of several series of PPS patients is as follows:
Patients with Post Polio Syndrome may suffer from weakness of the breathing muscles, namely the diaphragm and ribcage. Occasionally, this can be severe enough to cause symptoms of dyspnea on exertion and even at rest, poor clearance of respiratory secretions increasing the risk of pneumonia, and elevations in the resting arterial CO2 level. Measurement of pulmonary function tests in these patients usually shows a significant restrictive pattern (small lung volumes) on the basis on neuromuscular weakness.
If respiratory muscle weakness is severe enough mechanical ventilation may be required. Small mechanical ventilators have been developed which deliver breaths through a comfortable plastic nose mask. This is often performed while the patient is asleep at night and results in improved daytime function.
Patients with Post Polio Syndrome have a high incidence of sleep disturbances with poor sleep quality and frequent awakenings which may be due to several factors. However, the most important etiology to rule out is central, obstructive and mixed sleep apneas. Nocturnal hypoxemia and hypercarbia can lead to worsening of daytime function of the breathing muscles. Nocturnal non invasive ventilation can be used in these patients to improve sleep quality and reduce symptoms of daytime sleepiness, and perhaps improve daytime respiratory muscle function.
Many PPS patients reported some new difficulty with eating or swallowing more commonly in those with bulbar polio. Video fluoroscopy has been used for evaluation and has frequently revealed pharyngeal constrictor weakness. Laryngeal penetration and loss of the cough reflex may occur without symptoms, suggesting an underestimation of the presence and severity of dysphagia in this population. Many patients have already employed compensation such as altering diet, cutting solids into small pieces, chewing it thoroughly, taking small sips of liquids, eating slowly, and using postural maneuvers. Most patients with dysphagia had also experienced some progressive speech difficulty such as increased hoarseness, weakness, or slurring.
Limbs may be cold and cold exposure produces weakness. This is thought to be due to intermediolateral column involvement resulting is vasoparesis, venous pooling, and excessive heat loss.
A joint that is biomechanically disadvantaged may develop degenerative arthritis.
Long term disability and denial may result in social and psychological problems.
After the diagnosis of PPS is established, a patient conference is a convenient way to formalize treatment goals and begin patient education. These areas should be addressed:
This item is the "sine qua non" of all attempts at successful management of PPS. At the time of formal diagnosis, patients are often desperate, yet imbued with a belief in their own ability to overcome their disability through the "no pain, no gain" approach. This approach may have served them very well after their acute attack of polio many years ago but is now actually self destructive. Persistence in this approach of "overcoming" illness has led to a spiral of deteriorating function and frequently a parallel decline in self worth. Patients must understand the concept of "living with" PPS in order to lead the fullest life possible. An understanding of the need for lifestyle modification is rarely achieved at the first visit and is often best reintroduced by a knowledgeable Occupational or Physical Therapist and reinforced and monitored at subsequent physician office visits.
a) Muscular capacity can be increased by achieving increased strength or endurance. Strength can be increased through isometric exercise. However, muscles must be carefully selected for isometric exercises. Some muscles will already be functioning at their maximum. Exercise may actually have a deleterious effect by forcing these muscles beyond their metabolic capacity and producing injury.
b) Endurance may be increased, susceptibility to fatigue decreased, and long term deterioration minimized through appropriate exercise supervised by a physical therapist experienced with post polio patients. Almost all patients have initial difficulties with exercise programs resulting from overdoing. They may also equate fatiguing daily activities (which challenge the weakest musculature and do not provide an effective aerobic training level) to exercise. This can be an instructive opportunity for the patient in understanding the "Lifestyle modification" and to experience its benefits. Goals in aerobic exercise are:
c) Muscle capacity can also be increased by bracing, orthotics, or other aids which extend, amplify or substitute for muscles.
d) Pharmacologic treatment of fatigue: Some medications seem to raise the threshold for fatigue. These observations are, as yet, anecdotal and await confirmation from clinical trials.
Medications for the amelioration of fatigue must be understood as aids which can give a running start to the rehabilitation process. However, if they are perceived by the patient as a form of curative treatment, they will only forestall the day of reckoning.
a) PACING of activity is the logical consequence of a successful LIFESTYLE MODIFICATION. Implementing of PACING requires that patients identify for each of the activities of daily living the length of time they may participate before experiencing fatigue. They must then break up their activities into smaller modules of time, each of which is of less duration than the time required to produce fatigue. A corollary concept to PACING is ENERGY BUDGETING which imagines that one has a fixed expenditure of energy for each day and that this sum should be "spent" on activities of the highest personal priority. (Exceeding this daily limit may be conceptualized as spending principle or acquiring debt but probably correlates to metabolic injury of the motor unit through overuse.)
b) Other means of decreasing muscle load are diet when overweight, use of orthotics to improve mechanical efficiency, use of wheelchairs or scooters to save energy expenditure, and treatment of chronic overuse syndromes.
a) Attention to specific complications such as dysphagia, pulmonary dysfunction and sleep disturbances may require specific referrals. The goals of these referrals can be addressed with the patient at this first conference.
b) Functional consequences also result from overuse syndromes which can lead to joint deformity. Physiatry consultation can be helpful here and orthopedic intervention is occasionally required. Evaluate need for orthotic prescriptions (i.e., splints, braces, AFO's)
c) Somatization, depression, anxiety, and self worth problems may occur as capacity decreases. Referral for counseling should be considered (MSW, psychologist) or polio support group (see reference section).
d) Evaluate and/or modify work duties through referral to occupational therapist or vocational counselor.
Patients often present during a period of decompensation. Decompensation may be caused by even slight embarrassment in strength due to inactivity or injury superimposed upon aging. It may also result from slight increase in muscular work resulting from weight gain or increase in activities. In either case, a spiral of deterioration may result from potential overuse injury to the motor unit and subsequent decrease in functional capacity can result. Patients may easily become fearful and depressed at this ominous decline in their previously stable, if compromised, neuromuscular status.
It is important to clarify for the patient the difference between deterioration in function and deterioration from disease progression. In fact, there is little evidence that any loss of function experienced by PPS patients is due to progression or recurrence of polio virus infection. If patients can understand that opposing forces of muscle strength versus muscle load are acting near a capacity threshold, they will be quicker to accept PACING concepts, to employ an appropriate exercise program, and to utilize other elements of rehabilitation. In most cases, this will allow the patient to return to or approach the previous functional baseline. It is not difficult for patients to then minimize deterioration in function over the years by:
The patient with PPS is best served by having a physician who has experience evaluating post polio symptoms, formalizing treatment goals, and making the appropriate referrals such as those listed below:
When the Diagnosis is in question.
A Physiatrist is a physician with expertise in the orchestration of the rehabilitation process. Especially when disability is severe, complex, or when biomechanical problems are prominent, physiatry consultation can help with the initial planning and selection of specific exercise programs, physical therapy, orthotics, and adaptive equipment.
A Physical Therapist who is experienced regarding PPS will be of tremendous value in introducing and customizing the lifestyle modifications and in introducing the useful concepts of pacing and energy budgeting. Physical Therapists can also screen for inefficiency in movement resulting from deformity or weakness, assist in establishing your patient on a safe exercise program, and monitor for the almost inevitable initial over indulgence in that program.
Occupational Therapists are trained to assess the home environment and the patient's daily activities in order to restructure tasks, introduce mechanical aids like grab bars, and provide devices such as sock lifters which make possible physical activities otherwise compromised by disability. Instruction in PACING of routine daily activities and associated lifestyle modification can also be provided by an Occupational Therapist.
A speech pathologist can help in the evaluation and treatment of swallowing and speech problems.
A Pulmonologist can evaluate and manage respiratory dysfunction and sleep dysfunction.
A psychologist or MSW can evaluate and counsel regarding reactive depression, coping strategies, pain management and life style adjustment. This is especially important to help the post-polio survivor deal with the "reemergence" of a neuromuscular disorder they thought had been previously conquered.
Local education/support groups meet on a monthly basis in various locales, offering education, support, and social opportunities for polio survivors and their families.
Orthopedics, nutrition, and social work referrals for evaluation will occasionally be useful in specific circumstances.
Dalakas, et al. A Long Term Followup Study of Patients with Post Poliomyelitis Neuromuscular Symptoms. NEJM 1986;314:949-63. [PubMed Abstract]
Klingman, et al. Functional Recovery: A Major Risk Factor for the Development of PPMA. Arch Neurol '88;45:645-7. [PubMed Abstract]
Pezeshkpour & Dalakas. Long Term Changes in the Spinal Cords of Patients with Old Polio. Arch Neurol '88;45:505-8. [PubMed Abstract]
Sonies and Dalakas. Dysphagia in Patients with the Post-Polio Syndrome. NEJM 1991;324:1162-7. [PubMed Abstract]
Steljes, et al. Sleep in Postpolio Syndrome. Chest 1990;98:133-139. [PubMed Abstract]
Jones, et al. Cardiorespiratory Responses to Aerobic Training by Patients with Polio Sequelae. JAMA '89;261:3255-8. [PubMed Abstract]
Agre, et al. Late Effects of Polio: Critical Review of the Literature on NM Fxn. Arch Phys Med Rehab '91;72:923-31. [PubMed Abstract]
Munsat, ed. Post-Polio Syndrome. Butterworth-Heinemann, 1990.
Registered Charity No. 1064177
An Information Service for Polio Survivors and Medical Professionals
All enquiries, book requests, medical article requests, membership fees, items for newsletters and donations to
The Secretary, Lincolnshire Post-Polio Network
PO Box 954, Lincoln, Lincolnshire, LN5 5ER United Kingdom
Telephone: +44 (0)1522 888601
Facsimile: +44 (0)870 1600840
Web Site: www.lincolnshirepostpolio.org.uk
The Lincolnshire Post-Polio Network takes great care in the transcription of all information that appears at this site. However, we do not accept liability for any damage resulting directly or otherwise from any errors introduced in the transcription. Neither do we accept liability for any damage resulting directly or otherwise from the information available at this site. The opinions expressed in the documents available at this site are those of the individual authors and do not necessarily constitute endorsement or approval by the Lincolnshire Post-Polio Network.
© Copyright The Lincolnshire Post-Polio Network
Copyright is retained by The Lincolnshire Post-Polio Network and/or original author(s). Permission is granted to print copies of individual articles for personal use provided they are printed in their entirety. Links from other Internet WWW sites are welcome and encouraged. We only ask that you let us know so that we can in future notify you of critical changes. Reproduction and redistribution of any articles via any media, with the exception of the aforementioned, requires permission from The Lincolnshire Post-Polio Network and where applicable, the original author(s).
Original Think-tank, Cornwall,
Document Reference: <URL:http://www.zynet.co.uk/ott/polio/lincolnshire/library/easterseal/approach.html>
Created: January 1997
Last modification: 24th January 2010.